Scarlett Sees Red
link Scarlett Johansson Threatens to Sue Over Nude Photos – UsMagazine.com.
Of course, the FBI is all over this one. Apparently dozens of agents have volunteered their own personal time to work on this case. The amount of time spent poring over evidence will be astronomical. Staff will be pulled off cases looking for terrorist bombers in order to solve this pressing case. Removing nude pics from the Internet. Good luck with that.
Poor Scarlett is obviously aghast that someone would hack into her telephone and steal private photos of her. Living as she does in fairyland, she was unaware that just recently, Congressman Anthony Weiner had also suffered the fate of having his tighty-whities displayed on the world’s biggest billboard. Of course in Weiner’s case, he was targeting a specific audience. but unlike Scarlett, the only ones who may have been interested were probably gay men.
The philosophical issue is that pictures stolen from Scarlett’s phone are equivalent to having them stolen from a locked drawer in her house. I suppose that makes sense in theory and we won’t argue with the principle. But here is the essential seam which separates principled types from common sense types: theory is not reality. I can bake a pie and place it on my window to cool, but if it’s on a busy street, certain unprincipled types are going to take my pie. If I want to park my convertible on Chicago’s south side, it may not be a good idea to leave the Nikon in full display on the car seat.
Celebrities who need exposure to further their careers are often the ones to bleat about privacy issues when they know that their lives are lived under a microscope. At least Oprah and Joy Behar are smart enough not to take nude pics of themselves on their phones. Imagine the audience for that. Anyone who thinks cell phones are private are plain delusional. If Wikileaks can hack into top military secrets, what makes anyone think their Verizon account is safe? In real life, people regularly have things stolen from their cars, their homes, they may even have nude pics of themselves circulating without their consent, but those are the hazards of real life. Years and years of indifferent applications of punishments for law breaking has resulted in expectations of a certain amount of criminal behavior in our society. How many people these days don’t lock their car or house when they leave? What does it say when years ago, in many cities, it was common to see “no radio” stickers on car windows? Most petty crimes aren’t even prosecuted any more for the time and effort involved.
Celebrities should not live under the delusion that they are immune from the vicissitudes of life that normal people deal with. Celebrity status does not entirely insulate them from the society they choose to live in. They only benefit is that they get to publicize their moral outrage.